It’s hard to make dead mice funny. This is probably why the much darker director’s cut of Ratatouille will never see the light of day. Dinner for Schmucks, however, manages to not only make them hilarious but also integral to the story. These mice are the starring players in the intricate and meticulously crafted dioramas of Barry Speck, the titular schmuck played by the effortlessly ridiculous Steve Carell.
Paul Rudd, who had previously teamed up with Carell in Anchorman: The Legend of Ron Burgundy and The 40 Year-Old Virgin, plays Tim Conrad, a mid-level executive with a problem: His boss has invited him to a "dinner for winners" in which each guest must bring along eccentric person (schmuck) to be judged (ridiculed). The winner earns a trophy and the executive that brought him or her gets glory the glory. Although Tim is hesitant to participate, when he quite literally runs into Barry Speck, a walking library of oddities, he sees an opportunity that just might be too good to pass up.
While this synopsis may seem a bit confusing and convoluted, it only begins to scratch the surface of this consistently uproarious and at times touching film. Add to the mix one blind swordsman, two deluded psychics and a narcissistic conceptual artist with a penchant for wearing goat horns, and it soon becomes clear that this dinner is going to be one to remember. Let’s just hope the dead mice don’t spoil anyone’s appetite.